Articles

04th March 2008, 15:45

Conclusion

 

I would never publish this if I did not feel 100 percent sure about it. However there is no doubt in my mind that Guddo never played the entire game against chemistry.

The difference between the two players is so huge, that even though Guddo was a part of a good Danish team he would never be able to elevate his game so much in just three months. That would demand a whole lot more practice and to think that a gamer can change his style so radically without even playing is a sign that you lack knowledge of the game on a top level or that you have gone into depth with the situation.

Some might claim that Guddo simply had a good day but although Guddo hit the best day in his life, that would in no way explain how a change of style had taken place. It was two completely different people playing in the two matches. Since you cannot raise doubt as to whether Guddo played on LAN in Germany, we must conclude that the person playing the online final was not Guddo – this is based on the demo analysis and facts brought into observation in this analysis.

To broaden the perspective a little bit I have asked the opinion of several people that either plays at the very top or is highly active here:

http://www.satanion.dk/statements.htm (statements are in Danish)

DEL's verdict:

DEL delivered their verdict the 23rd of February 2008. In the headline it stated: “Case closed” and in it stood:

Serverloggen viser at det var guddo's ip, der blev spillet fra.Der er ikke afleveret eller henvist til anden bevismateriale.Vi har set på demoen og finder den ikke tilstrækkeligt overbevisende til at kunne bruge den i sagen. Derfor frifinder vi mTw, guddo og whiMp fra anklagen.”

 

The serverlog shows that it was Guddo’s ip from which the game was played. Other evidence has not been admitted or linked. We have looked at the demo and found it to be inconclusive in this case.Therefore we acquit mTw, Guddo and whiMp of all charges

 

It is in my eyes embarrassing admin work. Whoever was responsible for this case has either not gone to the proper depth of the matter or the person simply did not have the required proficiency to do so.

How can one go into this case and not use demos from former matches as a part of the evidence!? It is pure logic that in order to understand the style of the gamer, you need to watch prior matches and compare his style of play from those to the new demo with him. I have no doubt that if you chose to watch a demo from LANmount and then this demo of the final against Chemistry, you will, in 95% of the cases, find that Guddo did not play in the final!

Okay, it has been determined that the IP used was from Guddos home but that hardly proves anything. There is no guarantee that he was the one wielding the mouse – it could be anybody.

I hope you enjoyed reading this blog as much as I enjoyed writing it. I have spent a long time on it and I hope that that reflects off. I find the analysis to be thorough and precise; hence I cannot believe that Guddo was the one who played in that final. Thanks for your time.

 

 
Comments (10)

 

Page :
  • 1
(last year)  #1 nebu
nebu
well maybe he has 2 steam accounts? :D
turn on, tune in, drop out..
(last year)  #2 The1Crow
The1Crow
Guddo on laptop?! :D
Some ppl come into our lives and quickly go. Some stay ever!
(last year)  #3 Apollis
Apollis
CB and NGL would have made the same solution.
And when will both sides be posted? Bad work ArcadioN, remember always to have both sides.
(last year)  #5 Phil
Phil
CB and NGL haven't taken the circumstantial evidence into account, they have only taken the same evidence into account as DEL.

Oh and I hardly think you can blame Arcadion for presenting the facts as he sees it.
Last edited by Phil at 04.03.2008, 23:16

I'm forever blowing bubbles!
(last year)  #8 Apollis
Apollis
CB and NGL don't use demo at any circumstance in this situation. So what is there to do? As everyone else knows, demos can't prove anything 100% here. There a proof there goes Guddo's way (as told), and some speculation about the demo there goes against him.

Presenting the facts there benefits him, and leave out the facts there won't benefit him? Yeah I think I can blame him.

And letting this being posted, without having any 100% sure proof is on the edge to stupidity. You of all people should know that. You should have waited until you could show the proof I've heard you have.
Well if your proofs don't hold water, this only makes ArcadioN look more stupid then he already does, and you made a big mistake to post this. But I'm looking forward to your proof.

Btw. great work with the site, it's actually starting to become something great. If you look aside this little thing.
(last year)  #4 raxhe
 
Nice read, and great job Phil, very interesting
Most aimer of my city, the legend, my legend ;)
(last year)  #6 James3001
James3001
If it actually was his IP he could of just had a very good player on his id and ip taking his place :P you never know
www.sk-gaming.com/member/banks
(last year)  #9 Apollis
Apollis
And what if that was the situation? No way to prove it.
Tournaments needs to find something there prevent a player to just have another player visiting.

Recording VT during the match could be a solution in some way. Most people know each other in real life aswell. In this case many knows how Guddo and whiMp sounds like.
(last year)  #7 virc
 
but how can you check that
no way of proving unless you make everyone put live webcams on their pc's so people can see you play
(last year)  #10 Meibas
Meibas
the only save way to play is LAN Tours :) In every online game u can cheat.

phil nice work great blog.

Page :
  • 1


In order to post comments you must be logged in. You will be forwarded automatically to the feature you were trying to access.



If you do not have an account yet, you can register to the MYM Community in less than one minute.
Registering won't only allow you to read the latest coverage on current events, but also give you the oportunity to take part in an uprising gaming community and meet new people, aswell as new friends.Register now and be a part of the MeetYourMakers community.
 
Credits
Phil
Author
Last update : 04.03.2008 15:58
3 updates
This item was shown 18954 times.
6 people wrote a comment.
3 updates by 1 writers.
Last update was last year.
join the team

MYM playing two clanwars this week! + NGL matches coverage

WC3L - First two clanwar of the season The new season of WC3L has started. Yesterday we saw the firs ...

Read whole column

IFNG Copenhagen: A touchstone event?

Sweden against Denmark – A battle the public expected in the first Intel Friday Night Game of ...

Read whole column

show more columns
Without a word: WE.SkyTwo-time WCG winner, considered as one of the best Warcraft 3 players in history, an idol and role model for thousands of fans, featured in a the eSports movie beyond the game and despite to that all,...
show more articles
 
Shameless self promotion

STFU and SHOP!

All you can shop, right in there. MYM shirts, NNScript goodies, and other stuff the ESNation network has to offer. If you can't find it there, we don't sell it! Are you ready to STFU?
It has been confirmed from DTS-Cup 2009 that some of the top teams, such as fnatic, SK-Gaming, ALTERNATE and mousesports, won't participate in the tournament....
show more news
browse the galleries
 
Sponsored by
 
Statistics
Registered
Users: 1265955
Teams: 5703
Online
Guests: 4363
Members: 7
 
Advertising
 
Proud member of
about us | imprint | rss feeds | support | contact